Rift opens on new council

Photos by CHRISTOPHER TOMLINSON/The Daily Sentinel Rick Brainard takes the oath of office as a Grand Junction City Council member from City Clerk Stephanie Tuin on Tuesday. Brainard, who has been charged in a domestic violence case, said he did not notice the silent protest, below, by some people in the City Council chambers, who turned their backs as he was sworn in. Brainard and Phyllis Norris, shown being sworn in below, along with Marty Chazen defeated council incumbents in elections last month. All three have close ties to the Grand Junction Area Chamber of Commerce.

Recently elected Grand Junction city councilman Harry Butler, center, has his photo taken after being sworn in. BELOW: Newly sworn Marty Chazen, right, greets a well-wisher. Chazen was voted mayor pro-tem. Then, his vote helped approve the city’s restoration of membership in the Grand Junction Area Chamber of Commerce. See a photo gallery at GJSentinel.com. Photos by CHRISTOPHER TOMLINSON/The Daily Sentinel

Typically a mundane formality, the swearing-in of four new Grand Junction councilors Monday morning revealed tensions on several fronts.

For starters, protestors who have publicly rallied against Rick Brainard stood and turned their backs as the man accused in two domestic violence charges against his girlfriend was sworn into office.

Earlier in the morning, Brainard had a plea deal and sentencing date set for his court case — 4 p.m. May 17.

Immediately following the swearing-in ceremony, three of the four new council members voted in Councilor Sam Susuras as mayor, and new Councilor Marty Chazen as mayor pro-tem.

New Councilor Harry Butler abstained from the mayoral vote because he wanted councilors Jim Doody and Bennett Boeschenstein to be present. The two were absent Monday because of prior commitments. Their requests to have the vote for mayor and board appointments on a day when they could attend were not honored, exposing a glimpse of the contentious fissure and alliance between Susuras and the three new councilors against Doody and Boeschenstein. 

Illustrating yet another tiff, three of the four new councilors, Butler excepted, voted to reinstate the city’s $6,000-a-year funding for the Grand Junction Area Chamber of Commerce. Councilors, at their last regular meeting Wednesday, with the majority made up of mostly outgoing councilors, slashed the long-standing funding, arguing the chamber had become too political.

Indeed, the chamber did not endorse any of the three incumbents who were voted out of office in the April 3 election. Two of the four new councilors, Phyllis Norris and Rick Brainard have close ties to the organization, serving as past board members.

“Clearly, the chamber represents hundreds of businesses and these businesses employ thousands of our citizens,” Chazen read in a statement during Monday’s meeting. “I view the chamber as a valuable resource and vital economic development ally. In my estimation, the support and research the chamber provides far outweighs the value of dues the city pays to the organization.”

The number of supporters for the four new councilors outnumbered the roughly 20 people who showed to protest Brainard taking office. As he was sworn in, those protestors stood silently with their backs to the new councilor. Some protestors said after the display they will continue to defy Brainard’s presence on council and will follow through with a recall effort. Councilors cannot be recalled from office until after serving 90 days in office.

“It amazes me that many people would support an abuser. That oath just cost the city $45,000,” Mare Charlesworth said of Brainard, citing the cost of holding another election.

Brainard said he didn’t see the protest, but he didn’t begrudge the protestors their right to free speech.

“The people who voted for me voted for my business acumen,” he said.

Brainard said he would rather have waited to vote for mayor until Doody and Boeschenstein could have been present. Yet on the other hand, the two councilors, like the rest of council, had the opportunity to be present Monday, he said.


Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
Page 1 of 1

Earlier in the morning, Brainard had a plea deal and sentencing date set for his court case — 4 p.m. May 17.

I’m sure there will be demonstrators present on this date.

No problem with council voting in Sam and Marty but it couldn’t wait until all members were present?  Poor start. Really Rick?  You didn’t notice the protesters?

I hope you are more aware of your surroundings as a council member! There are several people with business acumen we can rely on to make good decisions who are acutely aware of their surroundings.

Not Freida Cook:  Am a relative - Ltpar
Right, wrong or indifferent the voters saw fit to elect Mr. Brainard to the Council.  His detractors need to accept that and if they don’t like it and have enough support start a recall campaign.  Other than that, quit whining and let’s see what kind of job the guy does.

@“Not Freida Cook”  Brainard had the apparent good fortune of not allegedly beating the crap out of his girlfriend until AFTER the election.  Are you saying that the voters would have voted the same way if he had done it before the election?  Yes, the voters have the option to recall him.  And I suspect that knowing what they know now, they will.

Page 1 of 1

Search More Jobs

734 S. Seventh St.
Grand Junction, CO 81501
970-242-5050; M-F 8:00 - 5:00
Subscribe to print edition
eTear Sheets/ePayments

© 2017 Grand Junction Media, Inc.
By using this site you agree to the Visitor Agreement and the Privacy Policy