Wave of appeals expected, DUI lawyers predict

Mesa County District Attorney Pete Hautzinger said Monday “a good number” of local drunken-driving cases have historically seen blood evidence tested at a state laboratory, which was under scrutiny in a report made public Friday.

Mesa County also uses the services of a private laboratory in DUI prosecutions, although Hautzinger didn’t know a breakdown of the labs.

“I’m sure the argument will be made,” Hautzinger said of anticipated legal challenges.

Potentially thousands of DUI convictions in Colorado could be appealed because of problems in the Laboratory Services Division of the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, defense lawyers said Monday. Prosecutors called that an overstatement.

Members of the Colorado Criminal Defense Bar said the appeals could come in cases as serious as vehicular homicides.

They also questioned why state officials did not release a report on the problems until Friday when it was completed in March.

The report said some employees of the lab at the state health department complained that a supervisor made statements suggesting a bias in favor of prosecutors. The report also said refrigerators containing blood samples were unlocked.

The report did not conclude that anyone lied on the stand or that any test samples were tainted, said Tom Raynes, executive director of the Colorado District Attorneys Council.

Raynes said the supervisor’s behavior as described in the report would be unprofessional and inappropriate, but “that doesn’t mean you lied on the stand or did something improper.”

Chris Urbina, executive director of the health department, said Monday that the problem was primarily a personnel matter and that the department acted promptly when it received the report in March. Urbina said the supervisor was transferred and later retired.

It was not immediately clear whether or how allegations against the supervisor of biased statements might have affected any court testimony she gave about test results.

The report on the lab was compiled by the Mountain States Employers Council, a human resources consultancy.

The health department laboratory is one of at least three that law-enforcement officials can use to test blood samples for alcohol content. It wasn’t immediately known what percentage of the tests are handled by the health department.

The report on the state lab is dated March 18 and was released by Colorado Attorney General John Suthers late Friday.

Sean McDermott, president of the defense attorneys’ group, criticized the attorney general’s office for not releasing the report sooner.

“When a prosecutor finds information that directly goes to the guilt, innocence or competence of an important witness, or any witness ... they’re supposed to turn it over immediately,” McDermott told reporters Monday. He said hundreds of additional tests might have gone through the lab since March.

Suthers released a statement Monday, saying he acted quickly to release the report once state prosecutors learned its findings could affect some cases.

He said the details of the report are a complex combination of issues involving civil, privacy and employment laws.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.


Commenting is not available in this channel entry.

Search More Jobs

734 S. Seventh St.
Grand Junction, CO 81501
970-242-5050; M-F 8:00 - 5:00
Subscribe to print edition
eTear Sheets/ePayments

© 2017 Grand Junction Media, Inc.
By using this site you agree to the Visitor Agreement and the Privacy Policy