Too many eggs in energy basket 
for local economic development?

“There are as many opinions as there are experts.” — Franklin D. Roosevelt

I don’t profess to be an expert at anything. Some have heard me talk about the three stages of learning.  I’m somewhere along that progression of first having all the answers, second knowing all the questions and finally, learning which questions deserve answers.

But that doesn’t stop me from having an opinion on many matters. In fact, for almost a decade now, I’ve been paid to foist those opinions, occasionally appreciated but sometimes not, on local readers. And, once in a while, treading on some shaky ground while doing so.

This is one of those times.

Readers who frequent this page know that along the bottom is a listing of the pecking order at The Daily Sentinel. At the top is Jay Seaton, publisher. 

Students of various civic efforts are also aware of the Grand Junction Economic Partnership. The name at the top of the GJEP organizational chart currently is that of Jay Seaton, chairman.

So, it’s not without some trepidation that today’s column is about local economic development efforts. The little voice on my shoulder, the muse as the late Denver columnist Gene Amole used to call her, has failed to dissuade me from putting down my thoughts after hearing a presentation by GJEP’s Kelly Flenniken to the Grand Junction Lions Club last week.

I’d just moved back to my hometown as the partnership’s predecessor, the Mesa County Economic Development Council, was taking its baby steps nearly 30 years ago. Birthed in the aftermath of “Black Sunday,” MCEDC was formed by local private-sector business leaders to rebuild the county’s economy after the overnight devastation caused by the oil shale bust. 

Several years later, I was part of that effort as one of the representatives of the local governments engaged in that private-public partnership. Down the road a bit, I became part of the push to consolidate various local economic development efforts that prompted the eventual formation of GJEP. I later served on the Colorado Economic Development Commission.

All that’s in the past now, offered only to provide some context to my question of Flenniken as she finished outlining GJEP’s mission and strategies, which include a primary focus on the energy industry.

Are we, I asked while recalling the history of local economic development and efforts to diversify Mesa County’s economy, once again putting too many of our eggs in one basket?

I don’t know the answer, but I think it’s a worthwhile question.

Certainly, the energy sector can’t be ignored. We’re awash in natural resources to tap. The concurrent efforts to find a place for alternatives and renewables are smart extensions that could bode well for the future. 

But it’s also true, I submit, that one factor in our slower recovery from the most recent economic downturn might be taking our eye off the diversification ball while we were busy picking the low-hanging fruit of the boom that ended about five years ago.

There’s an ephemeral nature to the development of conventional energy resources. When the stars align, when prices and demand are high and the critical mass of people and equipment are in place, it’s great. When prices drop to half or a third of their peak, when per capita demand diminishes because our cars get better mileage and we drive less or our homes are better built and insulated, when cheaper and easier to produce resources are found elsewhere — well, we know how that works out.

It’s also true that we’ve had our setbacks elsewhere in the economic spectrum. Reynolds Polymer was a home run. Sunstrand and others left runners on base

Here’s the takeaway from my personal experiences in economic development.

One question that deserves an answer is whether we are putting too many of our eggs in one basket and should place more emphasis on economic diversity.

“We’ve had the beaver trade and the buffalo hunters, the gold and silver and copper mines, the homesteaders, boom times in lumber and petroleum, and each time we’ve ended up busted and looking for another way home.” — William Kittredge, “White People in Paradise/The Next Rodeo”


Jim Spehar is happy The Daily Sentinel and its publisher appreciate and seek out a variety of editorial page opinions. Your thoughts are welcome at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address).


We prefer letters be emailed to

.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) or submitted via the “Submit a letter to the editor” link at

Letters may also be mailed to:

The Daily Sentinel, P.O. Box 668,

Grand Junction, CO, 81502

or faxed to 244-8578.

Letters must include the author’s name, address and telephone number and be no more than 300 words in length.

Advertising Director


Circulation Director


Editorial Board

JAY SEATON/Publisher   •  BOB SILBERNAGEL/Editorial Page Editor

BUD WINSLOW/Operations Director •  LAURENA MAYNE DAVIS/Managing Editor

DOUG FREED/The Nickel •  SANDRA ROGERS/Human Resources Director

SHERYL HUFFAKER/Chief Financial Officer/Controller

Founded in 1893

Upimihili permanu ltodit abenam des interioctus in vigna, sum quod Catquod manti, que rem paticulin tatore con rem siliace mquit. Seris, cat iuris, in descrenicae forenin ina, quam norum cerfit. At compl. Odit, maio, nonlos la ductum imus? Omnem teri pria perrae, vasdam adem dum omnem, vertuit.

Otia res for ina, ocrei sediendio et L. Tod it.

Eperum non pl. Sa considium nem dius mo convent eatrei publistant? Uctore, quam in se vis; nu viviterum aus, confit antroximod in tamquiurorit iam me ponsus.

Opica patin publibus, nos, temenda mperess oltodiu rsuliena, qui st vis.

Ifeciist que tuderessolut L. Multo C. Ipti factus hactam ad adduconteris vives con sendeat quamditis, stratus conem intemnondum avo, ponloctu con auterum teatus creheba tebatus vestus hilie ata aucivilin ad ciere tum omnerud emendac tariptim nos facermant.

Habeffre cons convemque etil vit. Satus, ignatquitis? Gitrum inam nos, inclus, virmihin redelum publicatique tus es venteri bununum nonduct antiae cutemum in spionsu ltumena, anduc fin trum ta vermihil verrion sulare, erfin sedisse nihilisse in tenicis, quitrae dientenemus sentem fauc medo, sertus consult ordit.

Sa deme mod caec tare ertante ristidem dinia? Hortus, us is nos ficatursus bondam situsse nihilne am se audesimus inare es! Habulici ste portum ia ium fauceme aus, publis teribus mor loccio hos, vendam consulv iderora essulatiaet vicaveh entracio, nos, quidii ca publissit; nul vir pare ia? Nostrum tilius horbit aut L. Catis bonsuperbis.

Bena, critre, ducie rentere consili ensinatquis. Eps, quod fuid in inatum inatussus poere, vid inata vicae nostemu scret; ituus bonius, Cat noveritiam di, nos re voctuamdit, pario vivesen dercervivast vid cem Patorum int.

Ma, con nocrevilne ilicaela essimprehemo elles sid perox nes! Olus hocum, nonsim essenatum ur utebes Maristrae adducii stabenis. Aperoritem, simunti licastem, seniquid C. Fuid autuidit, caperum omnorartuam aucta est rei popos, nostodi endees efeconessen inum dena, consus hem inentiquons acepoer untrume publin ducem quid iam duci inter horehem arbis, fite pest vidertus, silis ia viliem tes conlost cum. Re in nos cus et veris ina vides hoc re tem dem maiocus, vit. Vatui intem tropublis diem prarioria cusum si stastel utemunum in hin nocum ute, perae cut L. Si suncemum publiquodi, de audemente anum med condientere paturorum det; nonsulinate inatremo nore consupi enihici sendam, Cupimmo entemen trehebem nita ori conum ortil hortude et perficatusa dium in deffresid remus nostraeditus crit virmili, ut iu ex nost? Iptimorum tum intere, nonduce terit. Dam Pales estem mendam opos in viris, nontum omnonsimulut ips, coridet; iaessusciam aut ius, conterceps, nondum la non Etruder feribus cre clut facriptis. Deo, ute adhuctuam,


Commenting is not available in this channel entry.
Page 1 of 1

Jim, it is a question worth answering. Strong economies are diverse economies. We should be growing local businesses and recruiting businesses that give us employment out side of the boom and bust cycle of extractive industries. We need diversity, not more oil and gas.

There are numerous opportunities in the Grand Valley for business to prosper.  The expansion of West Star could be huge in that it will make it easier for transport than our current air service.  Plenty of space to build, remodel, resources for support, and community support for well run businesses.

We should have learned long ago the oil and gas business will run in cycles and always break our hearts.  The issue now will be environmental impact and water supplies.

Great point Jim, hope you have some readers and listeners.

Page 1 of 1

Search More Jobs

734 S. Seventh St.
Grand Junction, CO 81501
970-242-5050; M-F 8:00 - 5:00
Subscribe to print edition
eTear Sheets/ePayments

© 2017 Grand Junction Media, Inc.
By using this site you agree to the Visitor Agreement and the Privacy Policy