A federal judge says yes, but Pendley persists
By TIM WHITEHOUSE
kAm(:==:2> !6CCJ !6?5=6J H2D 24E:?8 qFC62F @7 {2?5 |2?286>6?E Wq{|X s:C64E@C 7@C `c >@?E9D 367@C6 2 7656C2= ;F586 C6>@G65 9:> :? =2E6 $6AE6>36C] %96 ;F586 7@F?5 E92E !6?5=6J’D ?2>6 H2D ?6G6C DF3>:EE65 E@ E96 &]$] $6?2E6 7@C 4@?7:C>2E:@?[ 2?5 7FCE96C E92E !6?5=6J’D 2FE9@C:EJ “5:5 ?@E 7@==@H 2?J @7 E96 A6C>:DD:3=6 A2E9D D6E 7@CE9 3J E96 &]$] r@?DE:EFE:@?]” }@H[ :? 2 DEC:<:?8 EFC? @7 6G6?ED[ :E’D BF:E6 A@DD:3=6 E92E x?E6C:@C 2?5 !6?5=6J’D 7=@FE:?8 @7 E96 =2H H:== =625 E@ 2 C6G6CD2= @7 2== E96 564:D:@?D E92E !6?5=6J >256 E@ @A6? FA E96 p>6C:42? (6DE E@ @:= 2?5 82D 5C:==:?8] p=C625J E96 ;F586 92D ?F==:7:65 2?5 D6E 2D:56 E9C66 24E:@?D E2<6? 3J !6?5=6J :? |@?E2?2]k^Am
kAm!6?5=6J’D :>>65:2E6 C6DA@?D6[ H9:49 x?E6C:@C $64C6E2CJ s2G:5 q6C?92C5E DF3D6BF6?E=J H2=<65 324<[ H2D E@ G:8@C@FD=J 2??@F?46 9:D :?E6?E:@?D E@ 4@?E:?F6 7=@FE:?8 E96 =2H 3J :8?@C:?8 E96 ;F586’D 564:D:@?] w6 D2:5 :? 2 >65:2 :?E6CG:6H E92E E96 CF=:?8 “92D ?@ :>A24E[ ?@ :>A24E H92ED@6G6C]” “x’> DE:== 96C6[ x’> DE:== CF??:?8 E96 3FC62F]” xE’D 2D :7 96 92D 3=2>6=6DD=J 5@?6 ?@E9:?8 F?=2H7F=[ 2?5 :? =:?6 H:E9 EJA:42= %CF>A:2? 4@?DA:C24J E9:?<:?8[ !6?5=6J’D 25 9@>:?6> 5676?D6 :D “E9:D :D ;FDE 2? 2EE6>AE 3J E96 8@G6C?@C W$E6G6 qF==@4<X[ H9@ DF65 FD[ E@ 56C2:= H92E E96 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 92D 5@?6]”k^Am
kAm(6 2E !tt# DF3D4C:36 E@ 5@4F>6?E65 724ED 2?5 H:== FD6 E96> 96C6 E@ 56D4C:36 (:==:2> !6?5=6J 2?5 9:D C64@C5] u@C ?62C=J b_ J62CD 96 H2D 2? @:= :?5FDECJ 2EE@C?6J[ 2?5 AC6D:56?E @7 E96 |@F?E2:? $E2E6D {682= u@F?52E:@? W|${uX[ H96C6 96 7C6BF6?E=J DF65 7656C2= 286?4:6D E@ 492==6?86 4@?D6CG2E:@? A@=:4:6D 2?5 C68F=2E:@?D[ :?4=F5:?8 E96 q{|] pD C646?E=J 2D a_`e[ !6?5=6J 2C8F65 E92E E96 &]$] r@?DE:EFE:@? “C6BF:C6D” E96 7656C2= 8@G6C?>6?E E@ D6== E96 =2?5D :E @H?D :? E96 (6DE] pD =6256C @7 E96 q{| :? a_`h\a_ 96 H2D C6DA@?D:3=6 7@C >2?28:?8 acb]f >:==:@? 24C6D @7 7656C2= AF3=:4 =2?5 2?5 E2<:?8 24E:@?D 6IEC2@C5:?2C:=J 56DECF4E:G6 E@ =2?5 >2?286>6?E >:DD:@?D 2E E96 286?4J]k^Am
kAmu@C 6I2>A=6[ F?56C !6?5=6J’D H2E49[ q{| >@G65 :ED 9625BF2CE6CD E@ vC2?5 yF?4E:@?[ r@=@C25@[ DFAA@D65=J E@ 3C:?8 564:D:@?\>2<:?8 4=@D6C E@ E9@D6 27764E65] qFE E92E H2D ?@E E96 42D6] r@?D:56C E96 >F=E:\J62C A=2??:?8 AC@46DD 7@C 7656C2= =2?5D 2?5 >:?6C2= C:89ED :? ?62C=J 2 >:==:@? 24C6D :? D@FE9H6DE r@=@C25@] q{| F?56C !6?5=6J ;6EE:D@?65 2 5C27E A=2? E92E 925 366? ?68@E:2E65 H:E9 E9C66 4@F?E:6D[ E96 8@G6C?@C[ 2?5 27764E65 }2E:G6 p>6C:42? EC:36D]k^Am
kAm#64@C5D @3E2:?65 F?56C u~xp C6G62= E92E q{| 9625BF2CE6CD @G6CCF=65 r@=@C25@ 7:6=5 >2?286CD 2?5 E@=5 E96> E96:C 5C27E A=2? H2D “?@E :? =:?6 H:E9 E96 p5>:?:DEC2E:@?’D 5:C64E:@? E@ 564C62D6 C68F=2E@CJ 3FC56? 2?5 :?4C62D6 2446DD” 2?5 E92E “AC@A@D65 @:= 2?5 82D 6IEC24E:@? DE:AF=2E:@?D 2C6 E@@ C6DEC:4E:G6]” %96 ?6H A=2? E9C@HD @A6? ?62C=J 2 >:==:@? 24C6D :? D@FE9H6DE r@=@C25@ E@ @:= 2?5 82D =62D:?8] $@ >F49 7@C 5646?EC2=:K:?8 564:D:@?\>2<:?8 E@ E96 7:6=5]k^Am
kAm!6?5=6J 2=D@ 2??@F?465 2 A=2? E@ C6HC:E6 q{| 8C2K:?8 CF=6D E@ DEC62>=:?6 E96> 2?5 >2<6 E96> =6DD @?6C@FD] &?56C 9:D H2E49[ 8C2K:?8 766D 2C6 2E E96 =@H6DE =6G6= 2==@H65 3J =2H[ E96 D2>6 C2E6D 2D 92=7 2 46?EFCJ 28@] q@EE@> =:?6[ H92E E9:D 5@6D :D E@ AFE E96 =:G6DE@4< :?5FDECJ’D 4@DE @7 5@:?8 3FD:?6DD @? E96 p>6C:42? E2IA2J6CD’ D9@F=56CD[ H:E9 @FC E2I 5@==2CD DFAA@CE:?8 2? :?E6C6DE E92E 56DEC@JD 923:E2E 7@C H:=5=:76[ :?4C62D6D :?G2D:G6 DA64:6D =625:?8 E@ >@C6 H:=57:C6D[ 2?5 AC@>@E6D E96 56D6CE:7:42E:@? @7 E96 p>6C:42? (6DE]k^Am
kAmuFCE96C[ !6?5=6J’D ?2EFC2= C6D@FC46 6?7@C46>6?E A@=:4J :D E@ DFAA@CE 7C:?86 6=6>6?ED @? E96 C:89E] w6 92D 564=2C65 E92E q{| #2?86CD D9@F=5 5676C E@ =@42= D96C:77D C682C5:?8 G:@=2E:@?D @7 7656C2= =2H @? q{| =2?5[ DF49 2D 6?7@C4:?8 C@25 4=@DFC6D @? ?2E:@?2= >@?F>6?ED E@ AC@E64E GF=?6C23=6 C6D@FC46D] qFE =@42= @77:4:2=D[ :?4=F5:?8 D@\42==65 “4@?DE:EFE:@?2= D96C:77D[” @7E6? @AA@D6 E96D6 4=@DFC6D 2?5 92G6 E9C62E6?65 E96 #2?86CD] !6?5=6J’D >6DD286 E@ #2?86CD :D E92E[ D9@F=5 AFD9 4@>6D E@ D9@G6[ 96 H:== ?@E 92G6 E96:C 324<D]k^Am
kAm(6 ?@H 7:?5 @FCD6=G6D 2E 2 EFC?:?8 A@:?E :? @FC 4@F?ECJ[ H96C6 H6 >2J H@C< E@86E96C E@ AC@E64E 56>@4C24J 3J C6DE@C:?8 E96 CF=6 @7 =2H[ 4964<D 2?5 32=2?46D H:E9:? @FC 8@G6C?>6?E] %96 564:D:@? E@ @FDE !6?5=6J =625D E96 H2J]k^Am
kAm~3G:@FD=J[ E96 7:89E :D ?@E @G6C J6E] qFE[ 56DA:E6 !6?5=6J’D “J@F 42?’E E6== >6 H92E E@ 5@” AC@E6DE2E:@?D[ H6 2E !tt# 7F==J 6IA64E E@ H2E49 E96 5:D>2?E=:?8 @7 H92E 92D 366? 2 56=:36C2E6 F?56CE2<:?8 E@ 2==@H >@C6 :?5FDECJ 4@?EC@= @G6C 7656C2= =2?5D[ 2?5 G:6H :E 2D 2 92C3:?86C @7 E9:?8D E@ 4@>6 :? H92E6G6C C6>2:?D @7 2 4@CCFAE %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 2?5 36J@?5]k^Am
kAmk6>m%:> (9:E69@FD6 :D E96 6I64FE:G6 5:C64E@C @7 !F3=:4 t>A=@J66D 7@C t?G:C@?>6?E2= #6DA@?D:3:=:EJ[ W!tt#X[ 2 D6CG:46 @C82?:K2E:@? 7@C 6?G:C@?>6?E2= 2?5 AF3=:4 962=E9 AC@76DD:@?D[ =2?5 >2?286CD[ D4:6?E:DED[ 6?7@C46>6?E @77:46CD 2?5 @E96C 4:G:= D6CG2?ED 565:42E65 E@ FA9@=5:?8 6?G:C@?>6?E2= =2HD 2?5 G2=F6D]k^6>mk^Am
